Mosley or Toney - who had the best career?

[Spyder]

Your response is rambling, and only semi-coherent. You are confused with your definitions, which is probably why you keep using the 135 Mosley as your preferred "prime" version.

I'm telling you that Shane Mosley got BETTER after 135. This should not be a hard concept to grasp. But to make things easier for you in this pretend matchup, James Toney beats any version of Shane Mosley.

PS... Roy's peak was not Ruiz. That was supposed to be the start of his swan song. He had already fallen off drastically at that point. He also had MULTIPLE career defining fights by then.